I recently finished reading Alchemy: The Dark Art and Curious Science of Creating Magic in Brands, Business, and Life by Rory Sutherland. It’s a book that takes everything you think you know about logic and turns it upside down. One of my favorite quotes from the book is, “The opposite of a good idea can also be a good idea.” That sentence alone sets the stage for how the author wants us to challenge normal thinking.
Why Alchemy?
Sutherland uses the word “Alchemy” to explain how some solutions look “magical” because they defy standard logic yet still work. He believes that people don’t always act rationally. In fact, we often do surprising things that go against what spreadsheets and data predict. As he puts it, “We must beware of becoming a slave to logic.”
In other words, while facts and numbers are useful, they can’t capture everything that goes on in our minds. Emotions, habits, and intuition also guide our choices. Sutherland says if we want to solve problems in business and life, we have to look beyond simple rationality.
A Few Memorable Quotes
Throughout the book, Sutherland uses a lot of catchy phrases. Here are some I really enjoyed:
“If you never do anything unexpected, you will never surprise anyone.”
This highlights his belief that surprising people can create powerful connections and results.“A flower is a weed with an advertising budget.”
He uses this to show how perspective can turn something ordinary (a weed) into something beautiful (a flower) just by changing how it’s presented.“Don’t look for logic in places where it doesn’t exist.”
A reminder that not everything people do can be explained with clean, tidy reasoning.“People don’t want the best product, they want the product that is good enough, convenient enough, and feels right.”
Here, he suggests that emotions and context play a massive role in why we buy things or make certain decisions.
Simple Yet Odd Examples
Sutherland’s examples are often amusing, yet they prove his point that logic isn’t everything. One classic one involves Red Bull. He points out that Red Bull tastes odd, costs more, and comes in a small can—things that would seem like a bad idea on paper. But people love it because it conveys energy and excitement. The very fact that it tastes and looks different helps it stand out.
Another interesting example is about expensive medicine. Sutherland notes a study where people felt more pain relief from a pricey placebo than a cheap placebo. It’s not the actual drug that’s more effective—it’s the higher price tag that tricks our minds into expecting a better result.
He also writes about making daily tasks feel easier through simple changes in how they’re framed. For instance, the Heathrow Express train to central London could have spent billions on shorter travel times, but people might be happier just having Wi-Fi and comfortable seats. The journey feels shorter and more pleasant, even if the clock says otherwise. That’s the real “alchemy”—changing the perception instead of just the facts.
The Power of “Psycho-Logic”
One of the big ideas in the book is something Sutherland calls “psycho-logic.” He explains that people operate on emotional or symbolic reasons that standard logic can’t always explain. For example, if a company wants to encourage people to choose an eco-friendly product, they shouldn’t just list facts about carbon footprints. They might also want to make the product look stylish or fun so that people feel good about using it, not just know it’s better.
He writes, “True influence comes from understanding both what people say they want and what they really want.” This is where he reminds us that hidden drives and desires can shape our actions more than we realize.
Using Alchemy in Daily Life
Even if you don’t work in marketing or business, Sutherland’s insights apply to everyday problems. He suggests trying “illogical” solutions when rational ones fail. For instance, if you struggle to wake up early, maybe you don’t just set an alarm—you place your alarm in another room so you have to get up to turn it off. It might sound silly, but little tricks that might seem irrational can sometimes solve stubborn problems.
He also encourages us to “test the absurd.” If we only do what seems normal, we might miss brilliant ideas. It’s a bit like brainstorming where no suggestion is too weird. That’s where the “alchemy” of discovering something new often happens.
Why This Matters
Reading this book made me see that life isn’t just about logical steps from A to B. Emotions, memories, and environment all matter a lot. Sutherland says, “People buy things for emotional reasons and then justify them with logic.” Think about how many times you’ve purchased something just because it felt right, then later found a way to explain why it was the smart choice. That’s the magic of alchemy at work in our own minds.
My Biggest Takeaway
My main takeaway is that sometimes the best way to solve a problem is to look at it from a totally different angle—an angle that standard logic might miss. As the author puts it, “When everyone else is looking in one place, it’s time to look somewhere else.”
If you read Alchemy, be ready to question many “common sense” ideas you’ve always taken for granted. You’ll find yourself nodding along to stories that prove being irrational sometimes brings better results than playing everything by the book.
Final Thoughts
I think Alchemy is a refreshing read for anyone who feels stuck or bored with the usual approaches to problem-solving. It’s full of humor, surprising cases, and a lot of quotes you’ll want to keep in mind the next time you’re facing a challenge.
Rory Sutherland doesn’t pretend to have all the answers. Instead, he urges us to embrace creativity, uncertainty, and the oddities of human nature. In a world that often insists on being perfectly rational, Alchemy reminds us that a little bit of “magic” can go a long way.
If you made it till the end, congratulations! Your attention span is better and improved at reading than a lot of people.
Like and share this newsletter if you found it interesting.